Sunday, September 25, 2016

Patriotism: Is It Really What We Think It Is?



I always used to think that showing patriotism for your country was always a positive and a peaceful thing to do. More specifically, I thought that simple acts of raising up the American flag and standing up when the national anthem was being sung were common acts of mandatory patriotism. Now I say "mandatory" because it is ingrained in our heads by society that the aforementioned acts of "patriotism" were compulsory in order to show respect for one's country. In my eyes, the act of displaying patriotism was a mandatory good: displaying patriotism for your country would positive for the morale of the country and others would respect you for it, but if you don't you would be shunned and looked down upon by the rest of society.

Image result for patriotism
Well, those views of mine were from a long time ago. It is now September 2016 at the time of writing this and things have definitely changed. Nowadays, subjects like discrimination, racism, and feminism dominate the stage. However, I never expected the notion of patriotism to form into such complex and heated controversial topic. I wondered how a solidified notion of patriotism could turn into one of the most controversial topics that plague America today. Then I turned to the dictionary in hopes of finding an answer to my question. When I looked “patriotism” up in the dictionary, it just defines it as “devoted love, support, and defense of one's country” and so I just thought of patriotism the same way as I did before thinking that the definition is the same as the past notions of patriotism. But then, I stumbled on something big: A nationally known San Francisco 49ers football quarterback, Colin Kaepernick. He was the first person who I have seen that has refused to stand up as the national anthem was sung. He argued, “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color. To me, this is bigger than football and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder." Upon deeper investigation of his claims, I found that what he said was true and even found a court case where a white police officer killed a black man with his hands up. Even though Kaepernick provided justification of his actions, he still received overwhelming criticism for not supporting and being patriotic towards his country. Upon reading this denunciation, I wondered: were Colin Kaepernick’s actions really unpatriotic? After reading The Cloudy Patriot by Sarah Vowell, I noticed that she mentions, “The true American Patriot is by definition skeptical of the government” (Vowell 7.11). Then it all made sense.
Image result for colin kaepernick kneeling down

The definition of “devoted love, support, and defense of one's country” does not necessarily mean that patriotism can only be represented through strictly positive means. “Love” can also refer to “tough love” that is sometimes shown by parents as lovingly scolding to their children in hopes of making them good people. “Support” can come in many ways including constructive criticism. Now when these alternate meanings of love and support and put together, it becomes clear why Kaepernick did what he did and how it was also an act of patriotism. Kaepernick didn’t stand during the national anthem to show his protest on the American government that blacks are not getting equal treatment. This action is justifiable and actually an admirable act of patriotism since he is showing his skepticism towards the American government, therefore making him a “true American patriot.” 

Image result for skepticismRelated imageImage result for patriotism

1 comment:

  1. I love how you connected patriotism from the Partly Cloudy Patriot to today. I especially liked how you broke down the dictionary definition of patriotism into its singular words. The examples and analysis for each word was extremely powerful. I look forward to reading more of your posts!

    ReplyDelete